More than 2 million cribs from seven companies were recalled Thursday amid concerns that babies can suffocate, become trapped or fall from the cribs. Most of the cribs were drop-sides, which have a side rail that moves up and down so parents can lift children from them more easily. That movable side, however, can malfunction or detach from the crib, creating a dangerous gap where babies’ heads can become trapped, leading to suffocation or strangulation.
The companies involved in the recall were Evenflo, Delta Enterprises Corp., Child Craft, Jardine Enterprises, LaJobi, Million Dollar Baby and Simmons Juvenile Products Inc.
No deaths were associated with the cribs, but there were reports of at least 16 entrapments of infants. In one case, a child was found unconscious and later hospitalized.
In the announcement from the Consumer Product Safety Commission, all seven companies recalled drop-side cribs. Delta and Child Craft also acknowledged problems with fixed-side cribs.
Drop-sides have increasingly come under scrutiny, with several warnings from the CPSC in the last year that the cribs can be deadly. CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum has pledged to ban their manufacture and sale by year’s end.
“This new recall announcement is part of a larger effort by CPSC to clean up the marketplace from many of these unsafe cribs,” said Tenenbaum. “Most of these recalled cribs have dangerous drop-sides, while the Delta crib can pose a danger to babies if the mattress support is installed incorrectly.”
CPSC urged parents to stop using the cribs and contact the manufacturers for repair kits to immobilize the drop-side or information to make the cribs more secure.
The recalls involved about:
-750,000 Jenny Lind drop-side cribs distributed by Evenflo Inc.
-747,000 Delta drop-side cribs. Delta is also urging parents to check all fixed and drop-side cribs that use wooden stabilizer bars to support the mattress. The company says the bars can be installed upside down, causing the mattress platform to collapse. CPSC spokesman Scott Wolfson said Delta “was not cooperative with providing the full number of units involved in the mattress support assembly problem.”
-306,000 Bonavita, Babi Italia and ISSI drop-side cribs manufactured by LaJobi Inc.
-130,000 Jardine drop-side cribs imported by Toys R Us.
-156,000 Million Dollar Baby drop-side cribs.
-50,000 Simmons drop-side cribs.
-40,000 to 50,000 Child Craft brand stationary-side cribs and an unknown number of Child Craft brand drop-sides. Child Craft ceased operations last summer and sold its name to Foundations Worldwide Inc., which did not manufacture or sell any of the recalled cribs but will offer rebates for some of them.
With Thursday’s recall, 9 million drop-side cribs have been recalled in the past five years. Drop-sides have been blamed in the deaths of at least 32 infants and toddlers since 2000. The cribs are suspected in another 14 infant fatalities during that time.
Congress is also concerned about the cribs. Legislation has been introduced by Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., to outlaw the sale and manufacture of drop-sides. A similar bill has been introduced in the House by Democratic Rep. Joe Crowley, also of New York.
Drop-side cribs have been around for decades, but consumer advocates say they are not as sturdy as those of the past. Older cribs had metal rods that guided the drop-side up and down. Many newer cribs have plastic tracking guides for the drop-side that critics say are more prone to breaking.
The Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association, which represents over 90 percent of the crib industry, urges parents not to use cribs with loose or missing parts. It also says consumers should not use a crib that is older than 10 years because it may not comply with current standards.
___
Online:
Consumer Product Safety Commission: http://www.cpsc.gov
Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association: http://www.jpma.org .AP
Drop side cribs have been around for at least 60 or more years. The problem with them is not the fact that they are drop side, but, that they are not made properly. Drop sides are a boon for parents because they make it easier to place a child in his crib, especially if he has already fallen asleep and you don’t want to waken him when putting him down in the crib. I think that instead of banning the manufacture of drop side cribs, they should be properly designed so they don’t fail and injure a child. I brought up a large family and used several drop side cribs (without all the new fangled “safety” features. If I felt that the drop side wasn’t safe. I tied it to the top of the crib side so it wouldn’t fall down. I suppose someone out there will say that that isn’t safe either. Well, I think we need less regulation in our lives and learn how to take care of ourselves, and not have the government do it for us.
“Drop-side cribs have been around for decades, but consumer advocates say they are not as sturdy as those of the past. Older cribs had metal rods that guided the drop-side up and down. Many newer cribs have plastic tracking guides for the drop-side that critics say are more prone to breaking. …”
and then
“….It also says consumers should not use a crib that is older than 10 years because it may not comply with current standards.”
Contradiction, anyone? if the older cribs are sturdier and safer, why should I go out and buy a new one that is more expensive, more flimsy and subject to recall???
I’ll stick to my 13 YO childcraft crib, still as sturdy and strong as ever.
I’ll stick to my solid wood 40 year old crib with strong metal springs and rails and double drop sides, that an adult could sit on and not collapse the crib.